I've given EL D the pizzle sticks instead of the bully sticks (only when I'm around to supervise), kong toys stuffed with biscuits, or specialty dog biscuits (like Sr. Joan's peanut butter; or Merricks mint; etc.). I've never had good luck with rawhide either with EL D or my previous basenji - pieces break off and have gotten "stuck" in the guts. I try to stick with biscuit type treats for the teeth rather than soft treats.
I've given EL D the pizzle sticks instead of the bully sticks (only when I'm around to supervise)…
What's the difference between a pizzle stick and a bully stick? Aren't they both cuts of the same bull [organ]? I guess I've always thought they were the same thing.
Magnum loves his bully sticks. They keep him chewing for hours!
I have not yet broken down and bought the bully sticks, but after hearing all the praise for them I might try them. Just a few questions…first, how bad do they smell? Do I need to worry about them smelling up the whole room or Tosca chewing them on our white living room carpet? Do they stain? Also, do you have to worry about them choking on them like you do the rawhide? I woudl obvisouly take them away when they get small, but do you have to worry about them breaking little pieces off?
I have not yet broken down and bought the bully sticks, but after hearing all the praise for them I might try them. Just a few questions…first, how bad do they smell? Do I need to worry about them smelling up the whole room or Tosca chewing them on our white living room carpet? Do they stain? Also, do you have to worry about them choking on them like you do the rawhide? I woudl obvisouly take them away when they get small, but do you have to worry about them breaking little pieces off?
I don't find that they smell much at all.. and less then a "well" chewed rawhide. They do not break into small pieces that I have found.. and they don't stain any more then a rawhide might… there is no dye in them, they are all natural...
I agree with Pat…I don't find that the Red Barn ones smell much at all. There are cheaper ones that do smell horrible IMHO, but with the Red Barn ones, the only sign of the smell is usually on Ruby or Brando's breath...the room definitely doesn't smell because of the sticks. I have had no staining on my bedding, the dogs bedding or my couch from the Bully Sticks.
The organic/free range ones that MacPack talks about don't have any scent to them at all from what I can remember...I think that was why Ruby didn't like them :rolleyes: .
Large bully sticks last several days for mine. I buy 12 inch lengths and take away the last 2 or 3 inches so they don't try and swallow them! I buy in bulk on-line and get ones that are "free range and no chemicals" but have to spend $120 at a time. Seems like a lot but lasts well over 6 months, for 3 dogs, so not too bad. They gnaw on the ends, and chunks don't break off. Tiny ones don't last as long so I get large ones. If you don't know what they are, don't ask!!! hahaha
Anne
What site do you buy yours at and how bad do they smell?? I found 2 online stores that have them way cheaper (50% less) than the store I buy from, but i'm skeptical to get them from a random website..
I buy from :
http://www.bullysticksonline.com/servlet/StoreFront
"Bullysticks on line" and they have almost no odor, don't require refrigeration.
I have ordered from them twice, and each order lasts many, many months. It seems like a lot at one time, but I almost never have to buy them any other chews.
Anne
Since you buy so many at a time, do they stay fresh until you get through them all?? I dont know if they can get old/stale, just wondering.. I would be willing to buy that many at a time, but only have 2 dogs and dont want them to go to waste..
I did buy some from the local store (very expensive compared to online) just to make sure the dogs liked them and they agreed with them.. and they love them! and the red barn didnt really smell at all! so thanks everyone who suggested them! I like them way better than rawhide!
Ohhhh - My dogs would not be able to relax enough to take 'er easy on one bully stick at a time… they devour them instantly (almost) Feeding them one daily would be super spoiling them (I don't). I'd have to rely on that gift to benefit me, i.e. steering thier attention from family/friends. Like the same as offering my son (10 yr old) a chocolate milk shake. mmmm-good! He/they would be happy - not bored/impeded with the social activity.
Meanwhile, Duke and Daisy - have tennis balls, de-stuffed toys, nyla bones - to keep them occupied enough to argue/chew/tug with. 
Ohhhh - My dogs would not be able to relax enough to take 'er easy on one bully stick at a time… they devour them instantly (almost) Feeding them one daily would be super spoiling them (I don't). ...
Wow! The ones I buy are at least 1 to 1-1/2 inches in diameter and 12 inches in length. One 12-incher lasts Magnum several days of frequent gnawing. Even my Rottweiler (RIP, Brutus My Boy) couldn't get through one in a day. IMO, good, thick bullysticks are the best!
I found some online that I like.. they are also about an inch in diameter, and 12 inches, but i cut them in half and give each dog 6 inches.. it takes them about 45 minutes to finish it.. I also got the braided ones, 3 braided together.. i havent tried those yet but i'm sure they will last longer..
overall, bully sticks are a great chew and I'm happy people suggested them! my dogs go crazy for them! when i brought the box in from UPS and put it in the closet, Diego was walking around the room with his noise in the air sniffing, until he figured out where they were!
I buy from :
http://www.bullysticksonline.com/servlet/StoreFront
"Bullysticks on line" and they have almost no odor, don't require refrigeration.
I have ordered from them twice, and each order lasts many, many months. It seems like a lot at one time, but I almost never have to buy them any other chews.Anne
Hey MacPack…
Something changed with the last batch of Red Barn bully sticks I bought and they smelled horrible :eek: :eek: :eek:...the whole house was stinking because of them and I bought them at 2 different stores, so I definitely needed to make a switch. Anyway, yesterday I bought a couple of the free-range ones to try again. Guess what...my "new to me" b-boy, Brando, loves the free-range odor free Bully's so now Ruby does too 
(she wants anything he likes :D). Thanks for the link, I just ordered a case...individually the jumbo thick ones are $7 a piece here...the case is quite a savings!
I would love to give Cory and Jayden bully sticks to see how they like them but the website bullysticksonline seems to deal only with large quantities. I'd like to have them try at least one before I buy in bulk. I haven't seen them locally. Suggestions?
Meanwhile, here is a thought for you to wrap your brains around: I went on Amazon to see what they had and, of course, there was a "new or used" price link. The mental picture of getting a box of "used" bully sticks immediately popped into my head! :eek:
Pat
Ewww, used bully sticks, ick!
The first time we gave her a bone after we brought Fiji home and she devoured it in minutes (not a scrap left) it freaked me out. Basenjis aren't exactly like other dogs, are they? 
My DH bought a bully for Fiji while I was out of town and it's the first thing she ever spent more than a day chewing - she loved it. I've never seen her spend more than an hour on any other chew.
Wow! The ones I buy are at least 1 to 1-1/2 inches in diameter and 12 inches in length. One 12-incher lasts Magnum several days of frequent gnawing. Even my Rottweiler (RIP, Brutus My Boy) couldn't get through one in a day. IMO, good, thick bullysticks are the best!
I don't usually spend too much of any chew - unless I know it will last a long time. Haven't seen a bully stick that thick - the ones I buy at Pet Food & More are only about 1/2 inch thick, 12" long and around $3 each. I imagine the fat ones are about $10 each??? Pricey - I might try it if I see ones like that. Thanks for the info.
I would love to give Cory and Jayden bully sticks to see how they like them but the website bullysticksonline seems to deal only with large quantities. I'd like to have them try at least one before I buy in bulk. I haven't seen them locally. Suggestions?
Pat
I got mine at www.bestbullysticks.com and have been really happy with them..
They are really cheap compared to local stores and you dont have to buy in bulk (but since I had to pay shipping i got a ton) but like 2 dollars for a 12 in thick one.. which I cut in half and give 6inches to each dog.. and on the website it says the are from free range cattle (it says what country but i forget) I even called to verify that.. when i opened up the bag of 30 bully sticks it did smell (and I was mad bc it said very little odor) but when I took them out individually and they actually chew them I have not been able to smell any odor.. I think it was just all of them together in a zip lock bag, I opened it and released all the smells!
My dogs go crazy over them.. so crazy it actually gets annoying sometimes! my boy will go to the door where i keep them and look at me and howl and jump up and down..
I used to cut them into 6 inch lengths, but I take away that last 2 inches, so they don't swallow it, and realized that by leaving them in 12 inch lengths, I didn't waste as much. I get them at PetSmart sometimes, they have a 36 inch for about 12 dollars, that's $4 per 12 inch length, after we cut them with pruning cutters. I gave out 4 to my 3 dogs (always an extra when Ed hoards 2) and they were so tired from dogpark they barely chewed before passing out
Anne
That's a good site, by the way! Great to know where to get them in a reasonable volume!
Anne
I go a different direction.
I go to the meat section and ask them to cut a beef leg into 1 1/2 inch sections.
I take it home, freeze it and give the dogs one each a day, frozen.
It takes them at least an hour to get the marrow out, its doesn't stink at all and it cost about $4.00 for 4-6 sections.
This is the marrow bone, and this is what I do in my house.
I go a different direction.
I go to the meat section and ask them to cut a beef leg into 1 1/2 inch sections.
I take it home, freeze it and give the dogs one each a day, frozen.
It takes them at least an hour to get the marrow out, its doesn't stink at all and it cost about $4.00 for 4-6 sections.
This is the marrow bone, and this is what I do in my house.
I do the same thing…I buy a week's supply, dig out most of the marrow and freeze them. I give Ruby & Brando one every morning in their crate when I leave for work. Ruby doesn't even watch me head for the door and she immediately digs in :D...and that is HUGE because she is somewhat crate phobic. Brando loves the bones as well, but he still cries a bit when I leave...but that is getting better and usually stops by the time I get to the bottom of the stairs.
I only give bullysticks when I'm around because Brando would finish it off during the course of the day and I like to throw them out when there is only about 2-3inches left as I'm afraid he could choke on it.
