Shock collar training

[sharronhurlbut]

Please rethink this method of "so called" training.
We can help you with other ways.

[lvoss]

Anyone considering the use of shock collar should read this article by the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behaviorists.

http://www.avsabonline.org/avsabonline/images/stories/Position_Statements/punishment%20guidelines-aversives%20effects-definitions.pdf

[Rita Jean]

If some people would learn the difference in a shock collar and ours but most of all COMMON KNOWLEDGE. Jaycee plays everyday and night and is with out this collar this is so she is safe and can run in the dog park and be free and have fun with out getting KILLED or HURT or RAN OVER BY A CAR.

Rita Jean

[tanza]

I have held off too, posting…. I am totally against any type of shock collar.. and add to that underground fencing... Take the time to teach and work with your pup... don't take the easy way.... and that is sooo right.. a 7 month old will mouth.. that is how dogs play and talk.... work to change the behavior....

[Rita Jean]

I said on here once any of you want to meet us 1/2 way at loose dog park with your 6 month old and you turn your puppy loose and we will. Jaycee will run and have a great time. Jaycee does bite us playing and we let her. Jaycee sometime wraps dog leash around our legs and we let her. Jaycee plays and runs and hunts and we let her. But when the day is done Jaycee is safe and has had fun. We have not hurt her and I bet we get as much love from Jaycee if not more then any of you.

Rita Jean

[Quercus]

@Rita:

If some people would learn the difference in a shock collar and ours but most of all COMMON KNOWLEDGE. Jaycee plays everyday and night and is with out this collar this is so she is safe and can run in the dog park and be free and have fun with out getting KILLED or HURT or RAN OVER BY A CAR.

Rita Jean

I don't understand your post. I am quite familiar with electronic collars. They are commonly called shock collars because they use an electronic pulse, or mild shock, to correct the dog or get the dog's attention. What is common knowledge?

[Quercus]

@Rita:

I said on here once any of you want to meet us 1/2 way at loose dog park with your 6 month old and you turn your puppy loose and we will. Jaycee will run and have a great time. Jaycee does bite us playing and we let her. Jaycee sometime wraps dog leash around our legs and we let her. Jaycee plays and runs and hunts and we let her. But when the day is done Jaycee is safe and has had fun. We have not hurt her and I bet we get as much love from Jaycee if not more then any of you.

Rita Jean

There is no reason for you to get defensive. You like your e-collar…great...lots of us have had bad experiences, and/or have done extensive research regarding the effectiveness and fall out of their use. Just a different opinion/experience. Believe me, our dogs are loved, well behaved, get to run, etc...there is no reason for you to think that your dog loves you more than ours do...that is ridiculous and offensive.

[tanza]

@Quercus:

There is no reason for you to get defensive. You like your e-collar…great...lots of us have had bad experiences, and/or have done extensive research regarding the effectiveness and fall out of their use. Just a different opinion/experience. Believe me, our dogs are loved, well behaved, get to run, etc...there is no reason for you to think that your dog loves you more than ours do...that is ridiculous and offensive.

Quercus… you are spot on....

[Rita Jean]

How many B's are in resuce today because people could not take the way they acted? How many are there because people gave up just did not keep trying?
If this helps just one person and they keep there B because things got better there is one less little baby with no home. Your right about one thing this collar is not for everyone you have to know what you are doing. If person uses it everyday for just a power thing then its wrong. However you give the air of _am a BAD person because I have used the collar. Any one of you that think this are so far off base it is unreal. I have said this once before my daughter and I almost both died at her birth. I can tell you now I think different then a lot of you and pain and hurt are one of those things. So do not point at me.

Rita Jean_

[lvoss]

I am sorry but veterinary behaviorists will disagree that shock collars are an effective method of working with problem dogs. Here is another article about the effect of Shock Collars on Dogs, http://www.joelwalton.com/shockcollars.html

[Quercus]

@Rita:

How many B's are in resuce today because people could not take the way they acted? How many are there because people gave up just did not keep trying?
If this helps just one person and they keep there B because things got better there is one less little baby with no home. Your right about one thing this collar is not for everyone you have to know what you are doing. If person uses it everyday for just a power thing then its wrong. However you give the air of _am a BAD person because I have used the collar. Any one of you that think this are so far off base it is unreal. I have said this once before my daughter and I almost both died at her birth. I can tell you now I think different then a lot of you and pain and hurt are one of those things. So do not point at me.

Rita Jean

I doubt anyone thinks you are a bad person. No one is pointing at you?!? You are putting all of that emotion out there yourself.

If you feel like you have to offer an option for people to train their dogs, that is fine…I feel like I have to offer a warning to people that using an e-collar on certain types of dogs, or using it incorrectly can make them fearful and aggressive. This is not a personal attack._

[Rita Jean]

No one said problem dogs just everyday B that we all know can be to much for some people. Unless you think B's are problem dogs.

Rita Jean

[lvoss]

@Rita:

How many B's are in resuce today because people could not take the way they acted? How many are there because people gave up just did not keep trying?

To me this is a description of a problem dog. A dog that is exhibiting behavior that the owner does not want and does not know how to manage. That same dog in a knowledgable foster home could be a dream dog but at the moment where the owners are feeling in over their head, yes, it is a problem dog.

[Rita Jean]

Owners are in over there head beacuse they were not ready for Basenji. We all know they are not sit on the chair and watch tv dogs. However to me I do not see this as a problem dog there behavior maybe normal just not to the owner.
Anyway as much fun as this has been ha! ha! I am off to bed granny gets up really early. I shall look on here in the morning to see what ever anyone else has to say.

Rita Jean

[tanza]

IMO… people should just say NO to shock collars... if they are not ready for a Basenji or any other breed... they need to learn first... before getting the dog.. and if they have the dog first.. they need to learn "reward" based training before just going to the easy way with a shock collar.. which could easily lead to a really nasty reaction from the dog.. regardless of breed.. and I totally disagree that they are not "sit on the chair, watch TV dogs...".. they can be.. without a doubt

[Quercus]

@tanza:

IMO… people should just say NO to shock collars... if they are not ready for a Basenji or any other breed... they need to learn first... before getting the dog.. and if they have the dog first.. they need to learn "reward" based training before just going to the easy way with a shock collar.. which could easily lead to a really nasty reaction from the dog.. regardless of breed.. and I totally disagree that they are not "sit on the chair, watch TV dogs...".. they can be.. without a doubt

Good point, Pat…mine are totally sit on the couch and watch TV dogs...add in: under a blanket, in your lap.

One thing that I always tell people about positive reinforcement training, vs. correction, or punishment based training, is that you won't do any harm with positive training...you might with punishment training.

[shep_18]

I ended up buying one anyway, and so far its great. I have tried everything under the sun so this wasnt me taking the "easy way out". This was my last resort. Some people hate shock collars and some people don't. He has had no bad reactions and i only use the lowest shock when i need to..so far i'm only using the beeping one which is tone only and no shock. The highest shock doesn't hurt me at all (yes like many people i was curious) its more of an annyoing tingling feeling which would only bother me if it went on for a couple minutes, which you are obviously not suppose to do. If used right i see no problem with it.

[nomrbddgs]

This person asked for an opinion on the pet store collars and since I had used remote collars for field work many, many, MANY (over 15) years ago, I gave an opinion. Everyone learns about negative and positive reinforcement differently and within different time frames. Most of us would not use these anymore, but would try to learn more positive reinforcement methods.

Oh, by the way, I did try it on myself before I put it on the dog and I never went up even half way-there was no need. Sometimes just the beep (or vibration on some) has the desired effect.

[Rita Jean]

Shep 18 I am happy things are going well for you. Your are so correct if used in the correct way they are not bad and so much better than having a puppy or dog get away and get killed.

Quercus and tanza
In my eyes if you two have 6 month old puppies that just sit on chair and watch tv there is something wrong with them. Jaycee full of life and plays and has fun the tv comes only at about 9:30 to 10:00 P.M. at night. Jaycee loves to play and watch outside wild animals in door so when I say do not sit and watch tv I am sure when she gets older she might but until then…....................

Rita Jean

[Quercus]

@Rita:

Shep 18 I am happy things are going well for you. Your are so correct if used in the correct way they are not bad and so much better than having a puppy or dog get away and get killed.

Quercus and tanza
In my eyes if you two have 6 month old puppies that just sit on chair and watch tv there is something wrong with them. Jaycee full of life and plays and has fun the tv comes only at about 9:30 to 10:00 P.M. at night. Jaycee loves to play and watch outside wild animals in door so when I say do not sit and watch tv I am sure when she gets older she might but until then…....................

Rita Jean

Well, here's the problem…you said "we all know these aren't sit on the chair and watch TV dogs"...and indeed, that is your experience with one, six month old, Basenji. Your shock collar worked with one, six month old, Basenji.

You a bring a different perspective here, which is great.....but so far, your only experience is with one, six month old Basenji. It is kind of early to tell what has worked, and what hasn't for Jaycee's long term training.

With all the six month old pups that have lived here (not that many compared to some on the forums), of course they ran around, shredded stuff up, played with the others, and acted like puppies. Then they all fell asleep on the couch, either with the other dogs, or the humans in the evening. There is nothing wrong with them :rolleyes: