I will weigh in on this topic As you can already see, people who agree on most other topics can disagree on this one, because there are risks to both choices. In our house, there is virtually no consideration given about collaring regarding who is a show dog, and who is not. Some of ours wear collars all the time, and some go naked. It all depends on the risk factors that each dog encounters.
*our two males ALWAYS wear collars, in case we mistakenly let them together and have to separate them. Querk wears a Nick Russell collar with a flat tag with phone numbers bolted to the material. Hippo can chew everything except a flat buckle collar off…so that is what he wears, with the same type of flat tag.
*the older two females wear Nick collars most of the time because the likelyhood of them wrestling is next to nothing though when Ivy was young, she somehow got her front foot through her collar up to the elbow, and we had to cut it off. She went nakey for a long time after that. The possibility that they might find a way out of the fence is much higher than the possiblity that they would hurt themselves with their collars this age.
*The trade off for Bella is challenging. She will wrestle heartily with Hippo, but she is also unfocused enough to get completely lost if she were to get out of the yard. The only collar I feel relatively safe having her wear is a very snug fitting snap buckle collar. If I see them enaging in a lot of neck biting rough play, I will often remove the collar.
As you can see, there is no 'right' answer for this one, you have to weigh your own personal concerns, and each dog's individual risk factors.