Great they are finally being recognized. I watched a show a few months back where they were training Basenjis at airports to sniff out drugs and other contraband in baggage compartments. The B's do well because they are small, can step over all the piles of baggage and of course, have such great noses it comes easy to them to be trained for this work!
Crate training
-
@jengosmonkey No, because the lining of the tray sits in the tray and is no higher than the edge of the tray. I need to get out there with a camera. Anyway, it is not a metal tray - heavy duty plastic.
Just noticed something interesting - the number of crates that their adverts claim are useful for puppy training but which are OUT OF STOCK. Is this for the same reason shares in dog-food and dog-supply firms are through the roof ? Pandemic Puppies ?
-
@jengosmonkey the dog in that advert is floating
-
@tanza
I have both. Use the smaller plastic in the car. The wire is too big and bulky for that. I'm not sure about having the crate where one sleeps until they are potty trained, for two reasons. One, they need to get used to being by themselves for situations that require it, and two, it's convenient at night to have it near the door so the pup doesn't pee or poo in your hands on the way out. The first month is the worst, getting up every couple of hours... -
@sanjibasenji - You should pick them up and carry them out... until they are older and can hold pee/poo, not let them figure out how to get outside. At night I wake them and take them out, carry out and then carry in back to the crate. And yes the first couple of months are the hardest and you miss sleep... but wake them up and carry them out. Don't expect them to hold it and walk outside... puppies are used to getting up and going potty, not holding it. Remember that when with the litter they have Mom to clean up after them...
And honestly I don't agree that at night they should be by themselves... the need to be with their human... -
@enquiring_mind Completely agree. Reminds me more of a rabbit hutch than a dog crate. 
-
@tanza said in Crate training:
@sanjibasenji - You should pick them up and carry them out... until they are older and can hold pee/poo, not let them figure out how to get outside. At night I wake them and take them out, carry out and then carry in back to the crate. And yes the first couple of months are the hardest and you miss sleep... but wake them up and carry them out. Don't expect them to hold it and walk outside... puppies are used to getting up and going potty, not holding it. Remember that when with the litter they have Mom to clean up after them...
And honestly I don't agree that at night they should be by themselves... the need to be with their human...I agree with all, except last sentence. If one doesn't teach them to sleep alone at night and during the day, it'll be a problem down the road when they have to be left alone. They may develop separation anxiety. My sense is that the basenji, and some other breeds, don't do well alone. The sooner they learn to spend some time alone, the less difficult it will be for them later when they have to be alone. Our work in this regard I believe has paid off. At first we were catering to him. He was training us. Then we followed the advice of our training pro, and began leaving him in the crate at night down stairs from our room. It was tough at first. But we stuck it out and within a few weeks he was going into his crate voluntarily. If we hadn't, it'd be really hard on him when we have to leave him in there for 2-3 hours when we can't be home.
-
@tanza Actually I have never had a puppy pee on me while being carried out to empty. They seem to realise from a very early age where they are headed when woken at dead of night. They hold it until they are outside and then unleash the floodgates.
-
@sanjibasenji said in Crate training:
If one doesn't teach them to sleep alone at night and during the day, it'll be a problem down the road when they have to be left alone.
That hasn't been my experience at all. The ones that were always kept close to me at night from the get go never gave me any grief when I left them alone. The two I adopted as adults that had not been close to their humans at night were my separation anxiety dogs......go figure.
"In order to get along with a Basenji, you have to be at least half as smart as the dog!"
-
@eeeefarm Not that difficult to figure. The ones who had had closer access to you at night had more confidence and could, therefore, tolerate being on their own. The adults with separation anxiety had probably never been given that confidence.
-
@zande - Exactly Zande, I carry them out... never had one pee either when being carried out... letting them try and figure it out at a young age, yes....
-
Curious how your experience runs contrary to the positions of professional trainers on crate training. I have yet to encounter any that advise sleeping with a puppy. Maybe I've overlooked them... All I can say is that their training techniques have worked for us and trying to sleep with Sanji prior to potty and crate training was not.
-
@sanjibasenji I'm sorry but I had to laugh out loud ! My opinion of professional trainers is, in any case - use them on other dogs, keep them well away from Basenjis !
But what trainer can add up the years of experience of breeding, rearing and owning a pack that @tanza and I have ? Its probably approaching 80 years ! 39+ for me and I forget how many for Pat, almost that number I think. @eeeefarm hasn't bred litters of puppies like we have, but she also has vast experience with Basenjis and between the three of us we can offer at least 90 years.
But you follow your trainer by all means, if it suits you. We will all three continue to give the same advice, based on years with this wonderful breed.
-
@sanjibasenji, I can't resist....."the only thing two professional trainers can agree on is that the third one is doing it wrong!"
I agree with Zande and Tanza, who have years of experience with the breed. I doubt many trainers have any, or at best limited, experience of Basenjis. However, the bottom line is what works for you.
Personally I have never consulted anyone about training dogs, although I have read a few books. The wisest I have ever read are those by Chuck Eisenmann, but he was in a class by himself. I saw him once in Toronto. His dogs understood everything he said and acted on his suggestions that were made in a conversational tone, no matter how complicated his instructions. True magic!
-
@sanjibasenji - There are good trainers and "not" so good trainers... some consider all breeds the same and train them the same... but in my opinion not true. I have always had my Basenjis in the same room as we sleep in... never an issue when we were not home and we worked outside the home so every day they were home alone. As I have said before, I was lucky that I could set up the house that they had access to the yard (12' privacy fences and locked gates, with a doggy door, house set back from the street). But knowing that we did work that was taken into consideration when getting into a breed and how to arrange the house. That said if you can't set up the home to give them space and you have to crate during the day... they must be with you in the evening/night time, not again confided to a crate. Too much crate time is a real issue, again in my opinion. In the breed for 30+ years, breeding and raising litters...
-
What I've learned agrees with all of that, except that I'd qualify that only while they are potty training would I crate them at night. I agree, from what I've learned about active dogs including basenjis, they can't handle much crate time during the day. Now that Sanji is potty trained and crate trained, we let him sleep with us. Up to that point, he did great at night in the crate, volunteering to go in. I disagree with trainers and others opposed to doggy doors and electric fences. We had good experiences for nine years with our last dog with this combo, and I've not heard any convincing reasons why it won't work with a besanji. Indeed, so far it's working great. But perhaps that's because of how we use them. I suspect others have had problems because they use them differently.
-
@zande
That's OK. I appreciate your experience and the advice you and other breeders have to offer. I find much of it useful. And it's probably good in your situation Sally that you can laugh out lout at others (indeed in writing no less). -
@sanjibasenji said in Crate training:
we followed the advice of our training pro
I have to wonder if this "pro" was experienced with Basenji's, or just dogs in general. Your dog isn't a newborn human, to be left crying in their crib until they pass out from exhaustion. IMHO, this is a horrible way to treat an animal who was taught by their natural mother to sleep with the entire litter.
-
My sense from this discussion is that the opinions being expressed by those opposed to crate training puppies are not professional trainers. Breeding an animal for 20 years will provide a lot of insight and experience with a breed and with dogs, I have much respect for that accumulated knowledge, but, not to sound rude, that does not make that person a certified or licensed trainer. We keep babies in a crib to keep them safe; we do the same for puppies. Just to be certain we're on the same page, I'm not advocating that any dog, puppy or adult, be crated all day long. I agree with not crating at night once the pup is potty/crate trained (the two work together well).
I have learned from several certified dog training professionals who use modern positive-reinforcement techniques. This includes Brenda Aloff, Michelle Lennon, and I've reviewed content from others including Zak George, and Ken McCann. They all say something very similar to what Michelle states in this video about common misperceptions regarding crate training puppies (and she also states her credentials).
[removed YouTube link]
Being a scientist myself with a Ph.D., I'm a skeptic of unproven claims from un-credentialed sources regardless of experience. Indeed, those who claim they are right based on experience raises red flags for me. I favor advice from those with the most recent and demonstrated evidence-based knowledge. John Maynard Keynes was reported to have said in response to a person questioning why he changed his view on on a policy matter, "Sir, when I encounter new facts, I change my mind. What do you do?" (That wasn't what he actually said, but it makes the point.)
The techniques I learned regarding crate training have worked, so I'm rather skeptical that Basenjis are so different than other dogs in this regard.
But as someone wrote above, "the bottom line is what works for you."
-
@sanjibasenji said in Crate training:
But as someone wrote above, "the bottom line is what works for you."
That would be me. Colour me amused. Ever since Karen Pryor invented or discovered or whatever "clicker training", the "all positive" gang have considered it the last word on training. As with anything else, there are a lot of "professionals" out there, some of whom are very good, some of whom have the paperwork but not the least clue of how to handle anything that doesn't work out "by the book". There is nothing new about operant conditioning, the methods have been known and applied for decades, (even before psychologists put names to them) but just lately everyone who has watched a youtube video or read a book is an instant expert. What training any animal comes down to is the ability of the trainer to observe and adapt to changing conditions, knowing from experience what is likely going to happen and quick enough to change the approach when something is not working.
Believe it or not, "old school" methods, while harsh, turned out more reliable performers. Once upon a time, dogs that behaved and obeyed off leash were the norm, not the exception. We've come a long way.....now so many trainers advocate never going anywhere without a bag of treats, lest the dog decide he doesn't want to perform. Ask any dolphin trainer.....a sated dolphin will blow you off, unless he is sufficiently bored to want to do the tricks, which is why they prefer to keep them hungry. Clicker training works well for teaching new behaviours, because it precisely marks the behaviour you are looking for. It works less well for eliminating unwanted behaviours. "All positive" trainers throw out half the tools in the bag, but actually they don't, they just don't label them correctly, e.g. "time out" is negative punishment, but we wouldn't want to use the "p" word, would we? Confining a dog to a crate away from people is negative punishment, so call it what it is. Sure, ignoring the crying will generally work (although not with all dogs), but is not my preferred method. Actually, you can get obedience from a dog by withholding your presence and affection and rationing both carefully, keeping the dog kennelled so it is bored and anxious to get out of there. In such circumstances the dog will obey if so doing means it gets more social time, and if disobeying gets it back in the kennel.
I have seen many, many changes in my lifetime. Some good, some bad. But a piece of paper does not a dog trainer make, and the lack of same does not negate someone's experience. Your eyes will tell you who knows what they are doing, and who does not....
"In order to get along with a Basenji, you have to be at least half as smart as the dog!"
-
@sanjibasenji said in Crate training:
My sense from this discussion is that the opinions being expressed by those opposed to crate training puppies are not professional trainers. Breeding an animal for 20 years will provide a lot of insight and experience with a breed and with dogs, I have much respect for that accumulated knowledge, but, not to sound rude, that does not make that person a certified or licensed trainer.
You "don't want to sound rude", but you clearly do_not_respect the contributions from well established Basenji Breeders in our community. You claim that you "favor advice from those with the most recent and demonstrated evidence-based knowledge..." and then you quote YouTube sources?
The Basenji Forum is made up of many types of members, from hopeful Basenji owners, to lifelong Basenji breeders and everything in between. Their opinions, insights, and knowledge are valuable -- even if you don't agree with them. No one here is required to be certified in any level of ownership or training. We share our knowledge and accept that we won't always agree. If you are looking for advice from "certified professionals", I would recommend that you stop looking on YouTube and find a local source that will work with you one on one.
